problem+progression

Here is our component skills matrix for our problem progression.

It was pointed out that we forgot to place a key and explanation of our problem progression so hopefully this will help:

In the chart, the "rules" are separated from the "tools" with a line. Tools and rules are explained below.

The "X" signifies that the rule/tool is applied to the before photo. The "?" signifies that the rule/tool either isn't applied or isn't evident in the before photo. The after photo demonstrates the application of the rule/tool in question. Boxes that are blank mean that the tool is either not applicable or not ideal.

When taking a photograph there is no absolute way to compose it. The purpose of the "tools of composition" is to assist in the artistic expression of a scene not the scientific collection of it. Because of this, the tools are suggestions not steps or progressions. A more complex problem like those towards the right side of the progression are more complex only because the composer has more options, not because he/she is required to take more steps to solve the problem. A successful composition doesn't have to include any of the common tools listed (as shown by the first photo in the progression) but it does need to have a purpose and a perspective. In order to achieve the desired purpose and perspective the photographer has to choose where to take the photograph. We call this "walk the scene." These three steps are necessary but not always evident to the viewer. The question mark next to these three "rules" signify that uncertainty. Because these steps are necessary, we distinguish them from the tools and call them rules.